Tariq Nelson

Dr. Mahmoud has another good read on the problems of sloganized answers

The difficulty is this: to find or develop and workable “Islamic solution”, one must abandon historical and pietist utopianism. Islamic history, from its earliest days, has never painted a rosy picture. Islamic societies prospered when they were open to learning from others: Sassanid, Byzantine, etc. The famous Prophetic tradition said: “seek knowledge (`ilm), even [if you have to go to] China”, and yet our young still seek knowledge (`ilm) only by going to Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, or Egypt, centuries after the Islamic world ceased to be a main depositary of knowledge.

The result is “Islamic finance”, “Islamic jeans”, and “Islamic Cola”, along with satellite channels that broadcast feel good televangelist speeches about Islam, and broadcasting songs about Hijab and the Prophet in between MTV-style videoclips. [More...]

Filed under: Sloganism over Reality